Article
Should You Exercise Your NSOs Before Year-End? The Income-Timing Decision
Exercising NSOs before year-end makes the spread ordinary income now, taxed up to 37% while your employer may withhold only 22%. The bracket and cash-flow questions to settle with your CPA.
The decision is not automatic. Exercise your NSOs before year-end and the spread (fair market value minus what you paid) becomes ordinary income this year (IRS Tax Topic 427), taxed at a marginal rate that can reach 37%, while your employer may withhold only 22% of it (IRS Publication 15, 2026). That gap is yours to cover.
How the spread is taxed when you exercise
Start with what will not change. An NSO without a readily determinable fair market value (the usual case) creates no taxable event at grant. The tax arrives at exercise.
When you exercise, you include in income the fair market value of the stock you receive, less the amount you paid (IRS Tax Topic 427). That difference is the spread, and it is ordinary income in the year you exercise, taxed at your marginal rate rather than the lower long-term capital gains rate.
This is where an NSO parts ways with an ISO.
Where NSOs and ISOs split
An ISO is built to defer that ordinary-income hit. As the IRS writes in Tax Topic 427, with an incentive stock option “you generally don’t include any amount in your gross income when you receive or exercise the option.” (The alternative minimum tax can still reach an ISO exercise, and a disqualifying sale can turn the gain into ordinary income, which is its own year-end call. We work through that in the ISO and AMT year-end decision.)
An NSO carries no such deferral. The spread is ordinary income at exercise, full stop. So the year-end question for an NSO is really a question about which year’s bracket you want that income to land in.
NSO vs ISO at exercise
| At exercise | NSO | ISO |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable event for regular tax? | Yes | Generally no |
| Taxed as what? | Ordinary income, up to 37% | No regular-tax income at exercise; AMT may apply |
| Employer withholding? | Yes, as supplemental wages (22% flat, 37% once over $1M) | No payroll withholding at exercise |
Sources: IRS Tax Topic 427 for NSO and ISO income treatment, and IRS Publication 15, 2026 for the 22% flat and 37% supplemental withholding rates and the $1 million threshold. Not tax advice.
Why 22% withholding leaves a gap
Here is the part high earners miss. Your employer treats the spread as supplemental wages and withholds on it, but the default flat rate is 22% (IRS Publication 15, 2026). A mandatory 37% rate applies only once your supplemental wages exceed $1 million in the calendar year (IRS Publication 15, 2026).
For most high earners the spread sits in the 22% withholding lane while the income itself is taxed at a marginal rate well above that, up toward 37%. Withhold at 22% and owe at your real marginal rate, and the difference does not disappear. It resurfaces as an estimated-tax payment or a balance due in April.
Timing makes the fix harder as the year closes. Earlier in the year you can raise payroll withholding and spread the catch-up across many paychecks, but later in the year the same shortfall has to come out of fewer checks, which can shrink a paycheck more than you want. At that point an estimated payment is usually the cleaner lever. (Confirm the mechanics with your CPA before you change anything.)
Exercise now or wait: the questions to settle
This is a bracket, cash-flow, and concentration decision, not a one-size answer. Settle four questions with your CPA or advisor before year-end.
First, the bracket question. Is your marginal rate likely higher this year or next? A bonus, an RSU vest, a spouse’s income change, or a planned break can move the answer.
Second, the cash question. Exercising costs the strike price plus the under-withheld tax. Do you have that cash outside the shares themselves?
Third, the expiration question. Options have deadlines, and a post-termination window can be short. Hold this one constant: a deadline does not care about your bracket.
Fourth, the concentration question. If you exercise and hold, how much of your net worth ends up riding on one company’s stock?
If you exercise and hold
Exercising and holding turns an option into a concentrated stock position, and that is a separate risk from the tax. A working ceiling many advisors use is keeping any single company’s stock to roughly 5 to 10 percent of investable assets, with the exact number depending on your situation (how liquid the rest of the portfolio is, how stable the company is, how soon you will need the money). The tax decision and the concentration decision deserve separate answers.
Frequently asked questions
Is the NSO spread taxed as capital gains?
No. The spread at exercise is ordinary income, taxed at your marginal rate (IRS Tax Topic 427). Capital gains treatment can apply later, to any gain after exercise if you keep the shares, but not to the spread itself. Confirm the holding-period details with your CPA.My employer already withheld 22%. Am I covered?
Maybe not. The 22% flat supplemental rate (IRS Publication 15, 2026) can fall short of a marginal rate that reaches 37%. Many high earners cover the difference through estimated tax or added withholding. Your advisor can size the gap for your bracket.Does waiting until next year lower my tax?
Only if your marginal rate is actually lower next year. Waiting moves the income, it does not erase it. The answer depends on your expected bracket, your available cash, and the option's expiration date.What is the $1 million figure I keep seeing?
Once your supplemental wages exceed $1 million in a calendar year, withholding on the excess is required at 37% rather than the 22% flat rate (IRS Publication 15, 2026). Below that, the 22% default usually applies to the spread.Where this fits
NSO timing is one piece of a broader high-earner plan that also covers RSUs, concentration, and the estimated-tax calendar. For the wider picture, start with the San Diego HENRY strategy.
None of this is tax advice, and the right move turns on numbers only you and your CPA can see. If you want a second set of eyes before year-end, our door is open for a complimentary conversation: schedule a time.
So which year do you want that spread to land in?
Related reading
-
Your Q4 RSUs Were Withheld at 22%. Your Real Rate Probably Isn't.
The same under-withholding gap, on the RSU side.
-
How Much Company Stock Is Too Much?
Sizing the concentration you create if you exercise and hold.
Talk this through
If any of the above applies to your situation, the next step is a conversation about your specific numbers rather than the general case.
Book my intro callA 30-minute call. No document gathering beforehand, and no obligation afterwards.