Article

Your Deferred Comp Election for Next Year Is Due Before December 31. Here's the Decision.

Your nonqualified deferred comp election for next year generally locks by December 31. What NQDC is, the 409A deadline, and the tradeoff to weigh first.

A December 31 deadline circled on a calendar beside a short planning checklist.

Your nonqualified deferred comp election for next year is a choice to route part of your 2027 salary or bonus into the plan before you ever receive it, and for a calendar-year taxpayer it generally locks by December 31, 2026. Once 2027 begins, the election is irrevocable.

What a deferred comp plan actually is, and how it differs from your 401(k)

Start with what stays the same. Both a 401(k) and a nonqualified deferred comp plan (NQDC, often governed by Section 409A) let you push income into a later year and skip tax on it today. That part is identical.

The difference is structural, and it drives everything else. Your 401(k) is qualified, which means the money is yours, held in trust, and shielded from your employer’s creditors. A nonqualified plan is not funded that way. The deferred money stays an unsecured promise from your employer until it is paid, which means it can be lost if the company becomes insolvent.

One point catches people off guard. Many assume a nonqualified plan has to pass the same non-discrimination testing a 401(k) does, the rule that stops executives and other highly compensated employees from getting a benefit the rank and file don’t share. It doesn’t, and people are usually relieved to hear it. That is the point of the plan. Because it sits outside those rules, an employer can offer it selectively to a short list of key people.

So there are two separate things you are really weighing. One is tax, the benefit of deferring income to a later year. Two is risk, both the company’s credit risk and the risk of locking up money you can’t easily reach.

Why the deadline is December 31, and why it won’t move

The deadline is not your employer’s preference. It is federal tax law. Section 409A governs these plans, and it requires the election to defer to be made before the year the pay is earned. For a calendar-year taxpayer, that means by December 31 of the prior year. The Treasury regulation on 409A sets the timing for the initial deferral election, and once the service year begins the choice is fixed.

Two narrow exceptions exist. First, if you are newly eligible for the plan, you generally get 30 days from eligibility to elect. Second, compensation that qualifies as performance-based can be elected as late as six months before the end of the performance period. Most annual salary and bonus deferrals fall under the plain December 31 rule, so confirm which bucket yours lands in with your plan administrator.

That is the obligation side, and it is real (a genuine December 31 cutoff, not a sales clock). What stays a choice is whether you defer at all, and how much.

The capped account versus the uncapped promise

Here is the contrast that surprises high earners. Your 401(k) deferral is capped. According to the IRS (IR-2025-111), the 2026 elective deferral limit “increased to $24,500, up from $23,500 for 2025,” and the age-50 catch-up is $8,000 for 2026.

A nonqualified plan has no IRS dollar cap. If the plan allows it, you could defer a large share of a bonus. That sounds like pure upside, but the reason there is no cap is the same reason there is real risk. The money is not protected. It is an unsecured promise, and you stand behind the employer’s other creditors if things go wrong.

Feature 401(k) Nonqualified deferred comp
Dollar limit on your deferral Capped. 2026 elective deferral limit is $24,500, plus an $8,000 age-50 catch-up No IRS dollar cap. Your plan document sets any limit
Who can offer or receive it Broadly available, subject to non-discrimination testing Offered selectively to key employees, outside those rules
Creditor protection Plan assets held in trust, protected from the employer’s creditors Unfunded. An unsecured promise, exposed if the employer becomes insolvent
When you elect You can start, stop, or change during the year Generally by December 31 of the prior year, then irrevocable
How you get paid You control distributions, subject to plan rules and required minimums Paid on a schedule you choose in advance, hard to change later

Figures in the table: IRS, IR-2025-111 (2026 plan year). The 401(k) elective deferral limit is $24,500 for 2026, up from $23,500 for 2025, with an $8,000 age-50 catch-up for 2026.

The decision to walk through before the deadline

The first filter has nothing to do with money. It is when you actually want this income back, and how much that timing matters to you. The trade-offs come after that.

Once you have answered that, the rest is sequencing.

First, name what you won’t touch. If you are not already maxing the qualified accounts, that capped but protected 401(k) dollar is usually the one to fill before the unsecured one. Confirm that order with your advisor against your own numbers.

Second, decide the payout before you decide the deferral. These plans ask you to choose how and when you will be paid, a lump sum in a set year or installments, at the time you elect, and that payout choice is also hard to change later. Deferring is only half the decision. When it comes back is the other half.

Third, size the credit risk honestly. A deferral into a stable, well-capitalized employer is a different bet than the same deferral into a company whose balance sheet you would worry about. Same tax benefit, very different risk.

Much of this sits inside the broader San Diego high-earner strategy of deciding where each dollar goes once the easy accounts are full. What you decide here also shapes what happens if you leave, which we cover in how a separation date interacts with vesting and your year-end bracket.

A few questions that come up

Can I change my deferral election after the year starts? Generally no. Under Section 409A, the election to defer the coming year's pay is made before that year begins and is irrevocable once it starts. The narrow exceptions are newly eligible participants (about 30 days) and some performance-based pay (up to six months before the period ends). Confirm which rule applies to you with your plan administrator.
Is my deferred money protected if my employer goes bankrupt? No, and this is the central tradeoff. A nonqualified plan is unfunded, so your deferred balance is an unsecured promise from the employer, not money held in trust the way a 401(k) is. If the company becomes insolvent, you stand with its other general creditors. The tax deferral is real, but so is that exposure.
Is there a limit on how much I can defer? Not an IRS dollar cap. Unlike the 401(k), where the 2026 elective deferral limit is $24,500 (IRS, IR-2025-111), a nonqualified plan has no federal cap on deferrals. Your plan document sets whatever limits exist. More room to defer comes with less protection, so the size of the deferral and your comfort with the credit risk move together.
Should I defer into this before maxing my 401(k)? That is a question to walk through with your CPA or advisor, not a rule. As a general starting point, the capped but creditor-protected 401(k) dollar and the uncapped but unsecured nonqualified dollar are not the same, even when the tax deferral looks identical. Where you are on funding the protected accounts usually shapes the answer.

The deadline is fixed, but the decision is not complicated once you take it in order. When do you want the money back, what will you accept to get the deferral, and does your employer’s balance sheet earn that trust?

If you would like a second read on how next year’s election fits the rest of your plan, a complimentary review can walk through your plan document and payout options with your CPA in the loop, before the December 31 cutoff.

Related reading

Talk this through

If any of the above applies to your situation, the next step is a conversation about your specific numbers rather than the general case.

Book my intro call

A 30-minute call. No document gathering beforehand, and no obligation afterwards.

Book my intro call