Article
Roth or Pre-Tax 401(k)? The 2027 Deferral Election High Earners Are Setting Now
How a high earner decides whether 2027 salary deferrals go Roth or pre-tax, plus the SECURE 2.0 rule that now forces catch-up contributions into Roth above a wage threshold.
Depends on one comparison: your tax bracket this year against the bracket you expect in retirement. Pre-tax wins if you’ll drop into a lower bracket later. Roth wins if you won’t. The 2026 deferral cap is $24,500 (IRS, IR-2025-111), and that choice rides on top of it.
Two questions, not one
Defaulting to pre-tax and moving on skips the decision worth making.
Split it in two. First, is your bracket higher now or in retirement? Second, do you even get a choice on the catch-up portion? They answer separately, and the second one changed under SECURE 2.0.
Start with what doesn’t change. Your 2026 elective deferral limit is $24,500, up from $23,500 for 2025 (IRS, IR-2025-111). The IRS put it plainly: “401(k) limit increases to $24,500 for 2026” (IRS, IR-2025-111). That ceiling is the same dollar figure whether it goes to Roth or pre-tax. The only thing in play is which bucket it lands in.
The bracket call
Pre-tax lowers this year’s taxable income. Roth doesn’t, but it comes out untaxed later.
So the comparison is your marginal rate now against your expected rate when you draw it down. A San Diego single filer hits the 32% bracket over $201,775 of taxable income, 35% over $256,225, and 37% over $640,600 for 2026 (IRS, Rev. Proc. 2025-32). Deferring pre-tax at 37% now and drawing it down at a lower rate later favors pre-tax. Deferring at 32% now and drawing down at 35% later, because your balance, a pension, and Social Security stack up, is where pre-tax works against you.
Keep in mind the input nobody runs: required minimum distributions. A large pre-tax balance can push your retirement bracket above your working bracket, the exact case where Roth would have been the better call, and a Roth conversion in a high-income year is a separate lever on that same balance. But if you expect to leave California for a lower-tax state and spend down early, pre-tax probably still comes out ahead. Name that condition before you decide, because it flips the answer.
| Decision axis | Pre-tax 401(k) | Roth 401(k) |
|---|---|---|
| This year’s taxes | Lowers taxable income now | No deduction now |
| Retirement withdrawals | Taxed as ordinary income | Qualified withdrawals untaxed |
| Who it favors | Higher bracket now than later | Same or higher bracket later |
| Catch-up over the wage threshold | Not permitted once prior-year wages top $150,000 | Required in that case |
Figures: 2026 catch-up Roth threshold $150,000 per IRS Notice 2025-67. The 2026 deferral and single-filer bracket figures come from IRS IR-2025-111 and Rev. Proc. 2025-32.
The catch-up that isn’t yours to choose
Here’s the part that surprises people. At 50 or older, the 2026 catch-up is another $8,000 on top of the $24,500, and $11,250 for ages 60 to 63 (IRS, IR-2025-111). Pre-tax or Roth used to be your call.
Not anymore for high earners. If your wages from that employer last year topped $150,000, your 2026 catch-up has to go in as Roth (IRS, Notice 2025-67). The test runs on your 2025 wages from that one employer, not your total household income.
I walk affected clients through it the same way each time. You can no longer take the catch-up as a pre-tax deduction, it goes in Roth whether that fits the rest of your plan or not. The base $24,500 is still your choice. The catch-up, for high earners, is decided for you.
Your best counter here: forced Roth catch-up hits you hard in taxes this year. True, you lose the deduction on that slice. But you also lock in untaxed growth on it, and if your retirement bracket lands anywhere near your current one, that piece was already leaning Roth. The rule just made one part of the decision for you.
The California layer
California taxes all income as ordinary income, including capital gains, with no preferential rate (California FTB). That doesn’t change the 401(k) choice directly, but it changes what you weigh it against.
A taxable brokerage account gets no state break on its gains. Roth money, once qualified, comes out with no further California tax on the growth. For a high earner staying in California through retirement, that lifts the value of the Roth bucket next to ordinary taxable investing. For one planning to leave, it matters less.
If you’re also holding concentrated equity comp or coordinating several high-income accounts, this deferral election is one input into a larger order-of-operations question. That’s the San Diego HENRY strategy problem, worth mapping before open enrollment closes.
FAQ
Can I split my 2027 deferrals between Roth and pre-tax?
Most plans let you set a percentage to each. The combined total still can't exceed the elective deferral limit, $24,500 for 2026 (IRS, IR-2025-111), with the 2027 figure set by the IRS later. Splitting is one way to hedge an uncertain retirement bracket. Confirm your plan's options with your HR or plan administrator.Does the forced Roth catch-up apply to everyone over 50?
No. It applies only if your prior-year wages from that employer were over $150,000 for a 2026 catch-up (IRS, Notice 2025-67). Below that line, you keep the pre-tax or Roth choice on the catch-up. The threshold is indexed, so it moves in future years.If I route everything to Roth, am I giving up the deduction for good?
You give up the deduction this year on whatever you send to Roth. In exchange that money grows and withdraws untaxed in retirement. Whether that trade helps you turns on your bracket now versus later, which is worth modeling with your CPA rather than defaulting either way.I have an old 401(k) and want to do a backdoor Roth. Related?
Different mechanism, same tax-bucket thinking. The pro-rata rule can complicate a backdoor Roth when you hold pre-tax IRA money. The walk-through is here: the [pro-rata rule and backdoor Roth](/blog/pro-rata-rule-old-401k-backdoor-roth). Evaluate the sequencing with your advisor before you convert anything.The decision splits into the piece you control and the piece SECURE 2.0 now decides for you. Worth running your real brackets before enrollment closes instead of defaulting to pre-tax out of habit. If you want a second set of eyes on both pieces, you can book a complimentary review. So which is it for you, higher or lower bracket when you finally draw this down?
Talk this through
If any of the above applies to your situation, the next step is a conversation about your specific numbers rather than the general case.
Book my intro callA 30-minute call. No document gathering beforehand, and no obligation afterwards.