Article
Self-Directing Inside the SCPMG Keogh and 401(k): How the Schwab PCRA Works
How the Schwab Personal Choice Retirement Account (PCRA) works inside the SCPMG Keogh and the 401(k) Plan for Permanente Medical Groups: choosing your own securities, what is excluded, and the default fund if you never choose.
Both retirement plans for Southern California Permanente Medical Group (SCPMG) physicians, the SCPMG Keogh Plan and the 401(k) Plan for Permanente Medical Groups, include a self-directed brokerage option run through Schwab. In the 401(k) it is the Schwab Personal Choice Retirement Account, or PCRA. Here is how the window works in each plan, what sits outside it, and what choosing to self-direct involves.
What the brokerage window is in each plan
The two plans describe it differently, and one is written down more fully than the other.
- The SCPMG Keogh Plan. The summary plan description refers to “the self-directed fund (the PCRA).” The plan’s audited financial statements describe self-directed brokerage accounts in which participants choose individual securities, limited to classes of investments set by the Retirement Committee. Schwab is the plan’s recordkeeper.
- The 401(k) Plan for Permanente Medical Groups. The summary plan description says you may invest up to 50% of your 401(k) account in the Schwab Personal Choice Retirement Account. It is optional, it may carry additional fees, and it requires an online application.
What the 401(k) PCRA leaves out
As of May 2023, the 401(k) Plan’s summary plan description excluded, among other things, private placements, limited and master limited partnerships, cryptocurrency, uncovered options, and any securities issued by SCPMG or an affiliated organization.
That list is dated, and the plan may have changed since. Where a summary and the plan document differ, the plan document governs. For the Keogh, the boundary is the classes of investment the Retirement Committee sets.
How much money sits in these windows
It is not a niche feature here. The master trust that holds the Keogh together with one other SCPMG plan reported $2,040,400,695 in self-directed brokerage accounts within $8,757,464,572 of net assets at December 31st, 2024. That is a trust-level figure for both plans together, not a number for either one alone.
What happens if you never choose
If you do not make a choice, contributions to either plan go to the age-appropriate Vanguard Target Retirement Trust for the year you turn 65. Using the brokerage window is therefore a decision you make on purpose, not a setting you drift into.
What deciding to self-direct involves
Taking the window up is a short list of concrete steps and questions:
- Know which plan’s rules apply. The 401(k) PCRA has a stated ceiling of up to 50% of the account. The Keogh PCRA is bounded by the classes of investment the Retirement Committee sets, so confirm what is allowed before assuming.
- Apply. In the 401(k) Plan the PCRA requires an online application.
- Check the exclusions. Compare what you have in mind against the list above, and against the plan’s current documents.
- Ask about cost. The 401(k) Plan says the PCRA may carry additional fees. Schwab Participant Services and your Benefits Handbook for Partners and Associate Physicians are where to confirm what applies to you.
- Be clear on what you would hold that you do not hold already. A window is for a specific reason, not because it is available.
The questions that apply to any plan’s window, including what it costs, who can manage it and what happens if you leave, are covered in what a brokerage window changes in a 401(k).
Where the Keogh election fits
Whether and at what level to fund the Keogh is a separate decision, covered in the SCPMG Keogh and 401(k) guide. This post stays with the window itself.
Talk it through
If you want to look at how the brokerage window fits your own accounts, bring your most recent Schwab statements and your Benefits Handbook. You can book a consultation to go through them together.
BAS Financial is not affiliated with SCPMG or Kaiser Permanente. Plan and company names are used only to describe the benefit structures discussed. The plan details above come from the Keogh summary plan description (April 2019, with summaries of material modifications from 2023), the 401(k) Plan summary plan description (May 2023), and the Keogh’s audited financial statements for plan year 2024.
Talk this through
If any of the above applies to your situation, the next step is a conversation about your specific numbers rather than the general case.
Book my intro callA 30-minute call. No document gathering beforehand, and no obligation afterwards.